Showing posts with label Al-Hidayah Mosque. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Al-Hidayah Mosque. Show all posts

Thursday, December 9, 2010

Where’s the Public Justification in Ostracizing Ahmadiyah?

Jakarta Globe, Indonesia
OPINION
Where’s the Public Justification in Ostracizing Ahmadiyah?
Aristo Pangaribua | December 09, 2010

In the most recent example of religious intolerance targeting a minority group in Indonesia, an armed mob attacked an Ahmadiyah mosque in South Jakarta last Friday. This was yet another wound for the Ahmadis, who have experienced hundreds of attacks in various places.

Our government seems reluctant to act on behalf of these minorities.

No one is ever convicted for ransacking and destroying Ahmadi mosques or homes.

It is not surprising to me because in 2008 the minister of religious affairs, the home minister and the attorney general essentially “endorsed” such actions by placing the blame on Ahmadis for failing to halt their religious activities.

Cabinet ministers even provided a “solution” to end the controversy by enacting a 2008 joint ministerial decree that prohibits Ahmadis from performing their religious services in public, because Ahmadiyah is considered a deviant sect of Islam.

Furthermore, the government is now discussing strengthening the legal status of the decree by turning it into state legislation (Undang-undang ).

Rights activists claim that such actions violate freedom of religion.

This has become a hot topic. Does the government have the right to interfere with a citizen’s private beliefs?

This kind of dispute does not just happen in Indonesia.

In the United States, the proselytizing of the Jehovah’s Witnesses sect has been restricted, partly because the group bans blood transfusions for its members, which has led to an outcry over children’s health.

The legalization of gay marriage in the United States is another case, as is the ban on wearing the full Islamic veil in public in France.

Nevertheless, I believe that in some cases the state does have the discretion to interfere with private beliefs to promote a broader “good” and to maintain order as a nation in general.

But what our government has forgotten is the role of explaining and justifying a given action that might be for the good of society.

The government, in deciding to restrict Ahmadiya’s actions, is acting on the basis of “good” religious doctrine.

The action was taken merely because Ahmadiyah tenets contradict the majority view of Islam.

The United States and France both use this discretion largely on the basis of health, security, community standards or nationalism rather than religious values.

Is this a sounder public justification?

Professor Gerald F. Gaus, from the University of Pittsburgh (Value and Justification: 1990), argues that in order to create public justification, a state action must be neutral toward different conceptions of the good.

A ban on the Jehovah’s Witnesses in the US state of Ohio was overturned in court because there was no sufficient public justification and it was deemed unconstitutional.

Public justification plays an indispensable role in the practice of democratic citizenship.

For Indonesia, which often goes on about its being the world’s third-biggest democracy, this requirement is extremely important.

If the term “public justification” seems too abstract, just ask the three ministers who enacted the joint decree how they would feel if the state used its power to prevent them from doing something they believed to be essential to their quality of life, without providing an adequate reason.

The use of coercive power itself is suspect in this case.

The “joint ministerial decree” is unknown in our legal hierarchy.

But the government is adamant this action is necessary to maintain “public order.”

Under the doctrine of separation of powers, it is the task of the courts to balance the state’s interest in restricting Ahmadiyah’s actions against the group’s inherent right to practice its beliefs.

It is imperative for the judges to make sure that the state is not acting for the wrong reasons and has provided a public justification for its action.

However, it is also true that in April 2010, the Constitutional Court declined to void the 1965 Blasphemy Law, which serves as the basis for the government entering the domain of religion.

The court rejected a motion for a judicial review, lodged by former President Abdurrahman Wahid and others, on the ground that the state needs to have this discretion to prevent turmoil and anarchy.

What makes it more confusing is that the joint ministerial decree cannot itself be tested in court.

Constitutional Court Chief Justice Mahfud MD was quoted as saying that the vague status of the decree makes it hard to challenge.

The bottom line is that our “third-largest democracy” has failed to produce a sufficient public justification for the use of its political power against a minority religion.

From what I understand, in a democracy, the citizen is entitled to an explanation when the state uses its power of coercion.

Where in the world is our principle of due process of law?

Aristo Pangaribua is a Jakarta-based lawyer and chairman of Pemuda Indonesia Progresif. He can be reached at www.progresif.net.

Copyright 2010 The Jakarta Globe

Saturday, December 4, 2010

Ahmadiyah mosque attacked for fun: Police

CITY
Sat, 12/04/2010
1:47 PM

Ahmadiyah mosque attacked for fun: Police
The Jakarta Post

JAKARTA: Jakarta Police chief Insp. Gen. Sutarman speculates that the perpetrators of a Friday attack on the Al Hidayah Ahmadiyah Mosque in Kebayoran Lama, South Jakarta, committed the violence for fun.

“They probably did it just for fun,” Sutarman told journalists Friday, adding that the police would hunt down whoever was responsible for the attack.

“The police are still investigating the case,” he added.

A group of unidentified men attacked the Ahmadiyah mosque early Friday morning. No fatalities were reported, but facilities such as lamps and window panes were smashed.

Mosque security chief Deden Sudjana said “the attackers claimed to be from the Majelis Pembela Rasulullah [Rasulullah Defender’s Council].”

The attack lasted less than a minute, he said, adding that the men were armed with swords and machetes.

“Police officers have been stationed at the mosque since last week to prevent attacks similar to those at Ahmadiyah mosques in Bogor [West Java] and Warakas [North Jakarta],” Deden said, as quoted by tribunnews.com news portal.

Police fired warning shots to disperse the attackers but made no arrests, he said. — JP

Jakarta Police Help Repel Attack on Ahmadiyah Mosque

Jakarta Globe, Indonesia
TOP STORIES
Jakarta Police Help Repel Attack on Ahmadiyah Mosque
Arientha Primanita, Nivell Rayda & Zaky Pawas | December 04, 2010

Jakarta. A group of about 50 people, dressed in white robes and wielding weapons, attempted to attack an Ahmadiyah mosque in South Jakarta early on Friday morning, but they were chased off with help from police officers.

Firdaus Mubarik, spokesman for the South Jakarta branch of Ahmadiyah, said the congregation was warned by police of the impending attack.

A number of members, along with three police officers, stood guard over the Al Hidayah Mosque off Jalan Ciputat Raya in Kebayoran Lama, South Jakarta.

“At 12:37 a.m., 50 people came to the mosque wearing white clothing and wielding sharp weapons like samurai,” he said.

Firdaus said the police fired six warning shots, causing the group to scatter. “The whole incident took about 10 seconds. It was recorded on our CCTV.”

The footage showed the group was mostly made up of teenagers armed with wooden canes and iron bars.

One assailant tried to pick up a rock while another attempted to climb the gates before the pack panicked and fled.

Seconds later, police and civilians were seen chasing the mob away.

One man from the group was detained and taken to the Kebayoran Lama Police station.

Jakarta Police Chief Insp. Gen. Sutarman pledged firm action against the perpetrators.

The damage from the attack was fairly minor, but pluralism advocates are more worried about what the attack means.

“This is proof that intolerance is really happening in the capital,” said Ismail Hasani, a researcher for the Setara Institute for Peace and Democracy, which recently released a survey showing that 45.4 percent of respondents from Greater Jakarta wanted the Ahmadiyah, a minority Islamic sect, disbanded.

Copyright 2010 The Jakarta Globe

Friday, December 3, 2010

Update: Indonesia Police Warn Ahmadiyah of Fresh Attack

Jakarta Globe, Indonesia
TOP STORIES
Update: Indonesia Police Warn Ahmadiyah of Fresh Attack
Arientha Primanita | December 03, 2010

An Ahmadiyah congregation in South Jakarta holding Friday prayers after their mosque was attacked early Friday morning. (JG Photo/Arientha Primanita)
An Ahmadiyah congregation in South Jakarta holding Friday prayers after their mosque was attacked early Friday morning. (JG Photo/Arientha Primanita)
Jakarta. Despite warnings from police that a second attack was being planned, members of the Ahmadiyah religious movement in South Jakarta went ahead with Friday prayers.

“We will keep doing our activities because it is only Allah we fear,” said Firdaus Mubarik, spokesman of the South Jakarta branch of Ahmadiyah.

A number of police officers had also been stationed at the Al Hidayah Mosque on Jalan Ciputat Raya in Kebayoran Lama.

The mosque was attacked shortly before 1 a.m. on Friday.

Firdaus said about 50 as yet unidentified people wearing white flowing robes, some of whom were armed with samurai swords and other weapons, before they scattered when police fired six warning shots in the air.

A window in the mosque was broken but no members of the congregation were injured.

One person has been taken into custody for questioning.

Last year, an unknown person or group attempted unsuccessfully to burn down the mosque.

Firdaus said they had only ever conducted their activities peacefully.

Copyright 2010 The Jakarta Globe

Armed group attacks Ahmadiyah mosque in Kebayoran Lama

JAKARTA
Fri, 12/03/2010
3:15 PM

Armed group attacks Ahmadiyah mosque in Kebayoran Lama
The Jakarta Post, Jakarta

A group of unidentified men attacked Ahmadiah Mosque Al Hidayah in Kebayoran Lama, South Jakarta, in the wee hours of Friday.

No fatalities were reported, but facilities such as lamps and window panes were smashed.

“The attackers claimed to be from the Majelis Pembela Rasulullah [Rasulullah Defender’s Council],” the mosque security head Deden Sudjana was quoted as saying by tribunnews.com news portal.

He added that the attack lasted less than a minute. The men were armed with swords and machetes.

“Police officers have been stationed at the mosque since last week to prevent attacks similar to those at Ahmadiyah mosques in Bogor [West Java] and Warakas [North Jakarta],” he said.

He said police fired warning shots to disperse the attackers but made no arrests.

Mob Attacks Ahmadiyah Mosque in South Jakarta

Jakarta Globe, Indonesia
NEWS
Mob Attacks Ahmadiyah Mosque in South Jakarta
Jakarta Globe | December 03, 2010

Al Hidayah Mosque on Jalan Ciputat Raya in Kebayoran Lama, Jakarta, Indonesia
Al Hidayah Mosque on Jalan Ciputat Raya in Kebayoran Lama, Jakart, Indonesia
Jakarta. In the latest example of religious intolerance in Indonesia, a group of unknown people attacked an Ahmadiyah mosque in South Jakarta early on Friday morning.

The sword-wielding assailants smashed the windows of the Al Hidayah Mosque on Jalan Ciputat Raya in Kebayoran Lama and left. No injuries were reported.

Mubarik, spokesman for Jakarta’s Ahmadiyah community, confirmed the attack.

Police are yet to comment.

In October, a mob of hundreds ransacked and burned down houses, schools and a mosque in Cisalada village, home to 600 followers of the minority sect, which is deemed deviant by many mainstream Muslims.

Last November, a group of conservative Muslims held a rally at an Ahmadiyah mosque in North Jakarta.

Copyright 2010 The Jakarta Globe
 
^ Top of Page