Monday, February 7, 2011

Yudhoyono: Punish Banten Officials Guilty of Negligence

Jakarta Globe, Indonesia
HOME
Yudhoyono: Punish Banten Officials Guilty of Negligence
Armando Siahaan, Amir Tejo, Dessy Sagita & Heru Andriyanto | February 07, 2011

Aminah has a police guard as she surveys the house where her son was killed on Sunday. (AFP Photo/Nurani Nuutong)
Aminah has a police guard as she surveys the house where her son was killed on Sunday. (AFP Photo/Nurani Nuutong)
President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono on Monday ordered a probe into the deadly attack on the Ahmadiyah community in Banten, including into negligence by local law enforcers and officials.

“I have ordered a full investigation, to find out the real cause and occurrence,” the president said.

“The purpose is that those who were negligent, guilty and violated the law must be punished.”

Violators could have come from both sides in the conflict, he said, but the probe should look specifically into whether there was negligence on the part of state authorities at the time of the attack.

“This includes if the clash could have actually been prevented, but prevention was done ineffectively, whether by the security apparatus or the local government,” he said.

“If this is this case, they need to be punished.”

His words came as one of his ministers said the sect deserved better protection, but another suggested followers could help themselves by detaching their beliefs from Islam.

Yudhoyono called on law enforcers and local military commands to be more proactive, professional and firm in preventing violence and taking action against those involved in attacks.

“I want all parties not to be lax, not to take this situation lightly,” he said.

“If there are signs [of conflict], take the appropriate measures, don’t wait until a clash and conflict erupt.”

Yudhoyono said he regretted the incident and offered his condolences to the victims’ families, but also hinted that the government would not revoke the 2008 joint ministerial decree on the Ahmadiyah, which he referred to as “the best option to solve the problem and to avoid horizontal conflicts.”

The decree prohibits Ahmadis from worshiping in public and from spreading their teachings but stops short of a ban on the sect.

“If the agreement was reached, embraced, abided to and implemented, then the conflicts, the physical clashes, the acts of violence could have been prevented,” he said.

Separately, Djoko Suyanto, coordinating minister for political, legal and security affairs, said on Monday that Ahmadiyah followers deserved to be protected like all Indonesians.

“They are our citizens, citizens of Indonesia whose safety is guaranteed and protected,” he said at the State Palace.

But he admitted that a solution for the sect’s troubles would not be easy to find.

“It is an issue of faith, belief, it is not easy to change someone’s mind-set,” he said, adding it was vital for law enforcers and communities to detect signs of conflict to prevent escalation.

Meanwhile, Religious Affairs Minister Suryadharma Ali said that to avoid animosity against the Ahmadiyah community, one option was for the sect to detach itself from Islam.

“Ahmadis can be asked to let go of their identity as part of Islam,” he said in Surabaya.

But he added he believed Ahmadis would refuse to leave Islam.

An Ahmadiyah spokesman, Firdaus Mubarik, told the Jakarta Globe that the solution offered by Suryadharma would not solve any problem as “belief is a very private matter.”

A similar solution imposed in Pakistan, he said, had only increased the number of victimized Ahmadis.

Editorial: Turning Blind Eye to Religious Bullies

Jakarta Globe, Indonesia
OPINIION
Editorial: Turning Blind Eye to Religious Bullies
February 07, 2011

But there are larger issues confronting our government and society in light of these attacks. Do we still respect our laws and the Constitution? Do we protect religious rights? The answers to these fundamental questions will determine what kind of a nation and society we will be in the future. (Antara Photo)
But there are larger issues confronting our government and society in light of these attacks. Do we still respect our laws and the Constitution? Do we protect religious rights? The answers to these fundamental questions will determine what kind of a nation and society we will be in the future. (Antara Photo)
Violence has no place in civilized society. An attack on the Ahmadiyah, a minority Islamic sect, which left at least three people dead and several others seriously injured must be condemned and those responsible must be immediately brought to justice.

The clash in Banten’s Pandeglang district on Sunday is the latest in a series of attacks against the sect. Over the years, the Ahmadis have faced increasing discrimination and prejudice from the government and mainstream Muslims opposed to the sect’s views. The Ahmadiyah followers have been chased away from their homes and mosques by angry mobs on numerous occasions.

Rival groups have long justified these attacks by citing an Indonesia Council of Ulema (MUI) edict which deemed the Ahmadiyah sect as deviant and a 2008 joint ministerial decree which effectively barred the group from worshipping in public and spreading their teachings.

In Sunday’s attack, a group of up to 1,500 angry villagers stormed a man’s home in Pandeglang and demanded that he stop hosting the Ahmadiyah’s activities there, according to news reports.

There is no question that the police must investigate the incident and arrest those who have caused physical harm. Law enforcement agencies have already come under criticism from rights groups for failing to protect the Ahmadis.

But there are larger issues confronting our government and society in light of these attacks. Do we still respect our laws and the Constitution? Do we protect religious rights? The answers to these fundamental questions will determine what kind of a nation and society we will be in the future.

The Ahmadiyah sect poses some complex problems for our society.

Do the followers of the sect have a right to practice their religion freely, despite policies and edicts barring them from doing so? What does the Constitution specifically say about the rights of sects such as the Ahmadiyah?

We have always said that our country’s strength lies in its ability to foster unity in diversity. We have also prized religious harmony as a key part of progress.

The government must therefore resolve religious problems quickly, firmly and fairly. If necessary, cases of religious violence should be brought before the courts.

It is a shame that the government has not dealt with the issue firmly, allowing it to continue unabated.

Sadly, we are bound to see more and more cases of violence and intimidation against religious groups like the beleaguered Ahmadiyah sect. But there must be clear and fair rules on how we must relate with each other in a free society.

Violence should never be part of the equation and should never be tolerated. Religion is an emotive issue but it too must be dealt with in accordance to the law.

Commission to Look Into Human Rights Violations on Ahmadiyah Attack in Banten

Jakarta Globe, Indonesia
NEWS
Commission to Look Into Human Rights Violations on Ahmadiyah Attack in Banten
Dessy Sagita | February 07, 2011

National Commission on Human Rights chairman Ifdhal Kasim said that they have formed a team to investigate the fatal attack on an Ahmadiyah community in Banten that left three dead.

“The team has started working today [Monday] and they will depart for Pandeglang soon,” he said in a press conference.

Ifdhal said that based on preliminary findings, the commission, also known as Komnas HAM, found at least eight serious cases of human rights violations.

“The brutal attack has violated many rights, including the right to live and the right to be free from torture and fear,” he said.

Some 1,500 residents attacked 25 Ahmadiyah members who had refused to leave the house of a local group leader in Umbulan village, in the Cikeusik subdistrict of Pandeglang, at around 10 a.m. on Sunday.

Ifdhal said that the state has absolutely no right to declare a certain sect as a devious sect. He said that the main obligation of the government is to protect its citizens regardless of their religion.

He added that the government should focus on enforcing the law instead of the ministerial joint decree or SKB.

“Evaluating SKB is not an issue for now. The most important thing is to conduct the proper legal process and arrest the perpetrators,” he said.

Yuniyanti Chuzaifah, chairwoman of the National Commission on Violence Against Women (Komnas Perempuan), said that the government should immediately revoke the joint decree because it has been used to legalize the brutal attacks toward the Ahmadiyah.

“We have recorded that from 2007 to 2010, there were 342 attacks on various levels at Ahmadiyah members. This indicates the government’s reluctance to protect its people,” she said.

Yuniyanti said that the House of Representative should also review the 1965 law about religion because it has been used by many people to justify violence against the minority.

Copyright 2010 The Jakarta Globe
URL: www.thejakartaglobe.com/home/commission...banten/421261

Indonesia demands probe into attack on Muslim sect

Yahoo News
AP
Indonesia demands probe into attack on Muslim sect
By ALI KOTARUMALOS, Associated Press Ali Kotarumalos, Associated Press – Mon Feb 7, 7:40 am ET
A police officer inspects the damage at the house of a member of Ahmadiyah sect after it was attacked by Muslim mob in Pandeglang, Banten province, Indonesia, Monday, Feb. 7, 2011. The machete-wielding mob on Sunday attacked the home of the minority sect leader in central Indonesia, killing three and wounding six others, police and witnesses said. (AP Photo)
A police officer inspects the damage at the house of a member of Ahmadiyah sect after it was attacked by Muslim mob in Pandeglang, Banten province, Indonesia, Monday, Feb. 7, 2011. The machete-wielding mob on Sunday attacked the home of the minority sect leader in central Indonesia, killing three and wounding six others, police and witnesses said. (AP Photo)
JAKARTA, Indonesia – Indonesia’s president ordered an investigation Monday into an attack on members of a minority Muslim sect after a gruesome video emerged of a mob beating several victims to death with machetes, sticks and rocks.

About 1,500 people stormed a house in Banten province on Sunday to stop 20 Ahmadiyah followers from worshipping.

They killed three men and badly wounded six others, while destroying the house and setting fire to several cars and motorbikes.

Indonesia is a secular country and has a long history of religious tolerance, but in recent years a hard-line fringe has grown louder and the government — which relies on the support of Islamic parties in Parliament — has been accused of caving in to it.

The latest attacks on Ahmadiyah — which drew rare condemnation from President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono — were captured on video and circulated widely on national television and the Internet.

The most disturbing clip, posted on YouTube, showed assailants repeatedly pounding two victims — who appeared to be dead — with heavy sticks.

A policeman came to the scene but his screams of “stop” were almost inaudible among dozens who shouted “Allahu Akbar” or God is Great.

The Ahmadiyah, thought to have 200,000 followers in Indonesia, are considered deviant by many Muslims and are banned in many Islamic countries because they believe that Muhammad was not the final prophet.

“I have ordered a comprehensive investigation to find out the real causal of the incident so that those guilty, or violating the law, can be penalized,” Yudhoyono told a news conference.

He also called on security forces as well as local governments to be proactive in taking action against the instigators of such violence.

“Don’t wait until the conflicts and clashes have already happened,” Yudhoyono said.

Many attacks on religious minorities in recent years have been carried out by members of the Islamic Defenders Front.

The hardline group pressured local authorities late last year to shutter a Christian church located in a densely populated Muslim area, and assailants stabbed Christian worshipper and beat a minister in the head with a wooden plank as they headed to prayers.

The Setara Institute for Peace and Democracy, a human rights group, says attacks on religious freedom by hard-liners are steadily increasing.

It says in 2010 there were 64 incidents, ranging from physical abuse to preventing groups from performing prayers and burning houses of worship, up from 18 in 2009 and 17 in 2008.

Police question suspects over Indonesia clashes

Yahoo News
AFP
Police question suspects over Indonesia clashes
Mon Feb 7, 2:20 am ET

An Indonesian policeman stands guard in Jakarta. Indonesian police said Monday they are questioning eight people involved in a bloody religious clash which claimed three lives at the weekend. (AFP/File/Adek Berry)
An Indonesian policeman stands guard in Jakarta. Indonesian police said Monday they are questioning eight people involved in a bloody religious clash which claimed three lives at the weekend. (AFP/File/Adek Berry)
JAKARTA (AFP) — Indonesian police said Monday they are questioning eight people involved in a bloody religious clash which claimed three lives at the weekend.

The incident, involving more than 1,000 Muslims who stormed a house in West Java on Sunday to stop the minority Ahmadiyah Islamic sect from holding worship, has been condemned by the government and rights activists.

National police spokesman Boy Rafli Amar said eight people are being questioned and investigations are ongoing, but police are yet to lay charges.

President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has instructed police to take firm action against the perpetrators, “to capture them and haul them to court if need be,” his senior adviser Daniel Sparingga told AFP.

“The president is deeply concerned and condemned the violence and said that the country must be firm in defending the constitution, that would never allow small groups to use religion to attack groups of different faiths,” he said.

Indonesia’s constitution explicitly guarantees freedom of religion and the country of some 240 million people, 80 percent of whom are Muslim, has ratified the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights.

But a government decree adopted in 2008 under pressure from Islamic conservatives bans the Ahmadiyah sect from spreading its faith, which includes the belief that its founder, Mirza Ghulam Ahmad, was the final Muslim prophet.

The group, which claims hundreds of thousands of members in Indonesia, has been repeatedly targeted with violence by members of hardline Islamic extremist organisations who operate with almost total impunity.

National Human Rights Commission chairman Ifdhal Kasim said Sunday’s incident was “embarrassing” as the police had made no effort to stop the mob.

“The police are biased and ignored their ultimate responsibility which is to protect the people,” he said.

“The government has no right to make judgments on whether a religion is heretical or not. Its job is to protect the people.”

Indonesian police probe attack on minority Muslim sect

CNN, USA
Indonesian police probe attack on minority Muslim sect
By Kathy Quiano, CNN
February 7, 2011 — Updated 1116 GMT (1916 HKT)
Indonesians hold hands together in Jakarta on January 7 to condemn the bloody religious clash which claimed three lives.
Indonesians hold hands together in Jakarta on January 7 to condemn the bloody religious clash which claimed three lives.
(CNN) – Indonesian police are investigating an attack on members of a Muslim minority sect that killed three people and injured five others.

The home of a Ahmadiyah sect preacher was raided Sunday by more than 1,000 people – some wielding knives, sticks and rocks, according to police.

Authorities said before the attack, security personnel were trying to persuade the preacher and about 20 other visitors to leave the home in Banten province on the island of Java.

Residents who oppose the presence of the Ahmadiyah in the area were demanding the group stop its activities, authorities said.

Police said the crowd grew unexpectedly and the situation turned violent. The victims were all members of the Ahmadiyah, according to local police chief, Lt. Col. Alex Fauzy Rasyad.

Amateur video taken at the scene using a small mobile device was handed to the organization Human Rights Watch.

The video showed brutal scenes of attackers pummeling what seemed like lifeless bodies of victims with sticks.

Human Rights Watch declined to reveal the source of the video, but similar pictures have been widely circulating on the internet, according to the group’s office in Indonesia.

We are grieving over the Ahmadiyah attack. The violence was not just against property but on human lives,” the sect’s spokesman Firdaus Mubarik told CNN.

Many Muslims consider Ahmadiyah followers as holding heretical beliefs. The sect believes Muhammad is not the last prophet.

Indonesia issued in 2008 a joint ministerial decree, prohibiting the sect – which has about 200,000 members in Indonesia – from spreading its beliefs.

Since then, many hardliners have often taken the law into their own hands, at times attacking the sect’s followers and their properties around the country.

Late last month, members of the hardline group, Islamic Defenders Front forced the sect’s followers out of their mosque in the city of Makassar, according to Human Rights Watch.

Activists have lashed out against this latest attack.

“For years, Indonesian authorities have sat idly by while mobs have violently attacked the Ahmadiyah,” said Elaine Pearson, deputy Asia director at Human Rights Watch.

“Today’s brutal killings happened because of the police’s failure to address hate crimes.”

Pearson urged Indonesian police to hold the perpetrators accountable.

Human Rights Watch said if the government is serious about stopping violence against the sect, it should lift a 2008 decree that prohibits the sect from practicing their religion.”

In a statement, Indonesia’s Institute for Policy Research and Advocacy also accused the police of failing to protect members of the sect.

Indonesian President Susilo Bambang Yudhoyono has condemned the attacks.

Security Minister Dyoko Suyanto called for an investigation, but also asked the sect to abide by the 2008 ministerial decree.

The police chief said an investigation is under way, and authorities are identifying the perpetrators.

“We hope the government will take firm action to stop the violence,” the sect’s spokesman said.

© 2011 Cable News Network. Turner Broadcasting System, Inc. All Rights Reserved.
URL: http://edition.cnn.com/2011/WORLD/asiapcf/02/07/indonesia.attack/
 
^ Top of Page